Sarah -
They’re Baaaaaaaack! Has it really been five years? I’ve quite
missed those pepperpot sociopaths. I mean, as much as one can miss pepperpot
sociopaths...
I have to admit, I've been looking forward to this story
since we began the Pertwee era. I have such fond memories of "Day of the
Daleks", but haven't seen it in at least seven years.
Harry -
Was it
everything you remembered it to be? I too saw it many moons ago and found myself
liking it even more this time around.
Sarah -
Happily, it was! I made
the entire family watch with me.
Harry -
It's always more fun with
more people on the sofa. But you know who's missing? Our friends Rob & Toby.
Can't believe we've almost gotten halfway through the Pertwee era without them
as our guides. I'm missing Rob's savvy interpretations and Toby's encyclopedic
asides. I've been keeping an eye on their publisher's website, but
there's still no sign of when we'll see Volume II of the series that inspired
our little adventure.
Sarah -
We are of one mind, Old Boy! I found
myself really missing Toby and Rob while watching "Day of the Daleks". They were
by our sides us for the first six seasons and I felt like we were getting by
without them for the past two -- but now I've had enough! I want our pals back
on the Sofa with us, already!
Harry -
Me too! I hope the next volume
arrives soon. Until then, let's continue to grope our way through this dimly lit
corridor.
Yes, Season 9 kicks off with lots of guns and mayhem, new
monsters and classic villains, and yet another international peace conference
for UNIT to safeguard. Everything old is new again!
Sarah -
There’s
so much packed into these four episodes. It begins so quietly, with the Doctor
trying, once again, to get the TARDIS operating properly. When Jo points out
that the TARDIS was operating when they went to the colony in space, the Doctor
explains that the Time Lords were in charge then, and “No one’s going to turn me
into an interplanetary puppet.” We even get a tidy little time paradox before
the Brig charges in to order them off to Auderly House to protect Sir Reginald
Styles from mysteriously disappearing freedom fighters!
Harry -
The
good production and on-location filming really elevated this story. The interior
and exteriors of Auderly House looked great. All those Ogrons, future
guerrillas, and UNIT troops racing around the grounds gave the story a great
spike of energy.
Sarah -
I know there are gripes about the Ogron and
Dalek attack force not being terribly menacing, but I love the image of them
stalking over the grounds.
Harry -
But there were the quirky little
moments too, like Jo "feeding the troops." There was something so sweet about
that.
Sarah -
I was slightly outraged by Yates' behavior towards
Benton. "Rank has its privileges," indeed, Posh Jerk! Yeah, I just called Yates
a posh jerk for showing up Benton -- got a problem with that?
Harry -
Jerky Yates!
Once the story kicks into gear, it really roars to life. Who are these
mysterious guerrillas appearing out of thin air? Are they heroes or villains?
They almost kill the Doctor and Jo before Jo ends up getting zapped into the
22nd century. And that's when it really gets groovy.
Sarah -
I was
half wanting the War Chief to show up and sex up the grooviness a bit.
Harry -
Well I can understand that.
I loved - LOVED - the
future sets. One room had the Controller in his white swivel chair, issuing
commands to a team of identical looking assistants (especially loved the
hand-waving action). The other room had the comfy cushions for everyone to
lounge on, even though the actors seemed to have an awkward time of it. I love
the 70s vision of the future. It's so funky!
Sarah -
The cushions
gave me some ideas for a redesign of the Sofa, if you're up for a bit of
lounging... of Rassilon.
Harry -
We could kick the cushions to the
floor and sprawl out. I'll bring some grapes next time.
One curious
point: there was so much interesting stuff going on, I barely noticed that the
Daleks were barely seen for the first half of the story.
Sarah -
Oh
yes, them. It does eventually become apparent that the Daleks were a late
addition to the story. Also, if I can quibble just a wee bit, the blue Daleks
didn't really have proper Dalek voices, did they? I can't even tell you how
bothered I was by that.
Harry -
Yeah, the Dalek voices seemed a bit
meek here. Same with the Ogrons. I remember seeing pictures of the Ogrons as a
kid and thinking they were fantastic terrifying monsters... only to find them as
subservient guard dogs in this story. Meh.
Sarah -
The Ogrons are
definitely striking. It’s long past time for a return, would you say? They will
have escaped their Dalek overlords by that point and found a way to bring their
own havoc to the universe. Or, perhaps a prequel about how they became the
slaves of the Daleks.
Harry -
What we lose in limited screen time for
the Daleks, we more than make up for in action sequences. The Doctor gets to
roar around in a Jeep, and his escape with Jo on the Randomly Placed Three
Wheeler was awesome.
Sarah -
There’s little as exciting as a
three-mile-per-hour chase!
Harry -
Health and Safety must have been going mad over that stunt.
Everything finally converges back
at Auderly House in the 20th century. It's going to kill me every time we see a
TV announcer in the Pertwee era. Alex MacIntosh was an actual TV announcer at
the time, but his brief role cried out for more Michael Wisher!
Sarah -
I’m starting to think that every story cries out for more Michael Wisher.
Harry -
Hear, hear!
Sarah -
Just a few more seasons, my friend.
With no Wisher to tide us over, I was
happy to make due with Aubrey Woods’ brilliant performance as the controller. He
started out a mere lackey of the Daleks, but managed to redeem himself in the
end by helping the Doctor and Jo escape. Bureaucrats so rarely have that
opportunity in the Third Doctor’s run.
While looking up information on
Woods, I learned that he died earlier this month. He's perhaps best known for
performing "Candy Man" in Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory.
Harry -
Very sad and untimely. We've had a couple of untimely deaths happen during this marathon. Aubrey Woods will certainly not be forgotten; he was fantastic in this role.
Back to the assault on the house. Would you call it an assault, or
more like a slow procession of three Daleks and some Ogrons? The visuals failed
there, unfortunately.
Sarah -
As I mentioned above, this little
sequence, while disappointing, manages to warm my heart in only a way Doctor Who
can. I spent so many hours defending the series against attack back in the 80s.
This scene is exactly the sort of thing I had to defend and one of the things I
love so much about the show.
Harry -
Overall though, this was a nice
comeback story for the Daleks. They are still at their scheming, dominating, and
exterminating, now in colour!
Sarah -
It’s a whole new Technicolor
universe!
Harry -
"Day of the Daleks" is one of those stories that
captures all of the Pertwee era. The action and stunts, the classic enemies, the
bureaucrats and conferences, and some otherworldly time travel to sort out. For
me, this one gets better with every viewing.
Sarah -
It absolutely
does!
Best Line: “That’s a most good-humored wine. A touch sardonic
perhaps, but not cynical.” It’s one of my favorite lines ever in Doctor Who and
I was eagerly awaiting it from the first note of the opening theme!
Favorite Moment: When the Doctor and Jo are tied up in the cellar. The
Doctor is trying to figure out what’s going on, and Jo responds with, “I’m the
one who’s supposed to be asking the questions.” I laughed out loud – we can’t
say Jo doesn’t know her place!
Lasting Image: The fast-paced ATV chase.
8/10
Harry -
Best Line: "A family of Quislings, eh?" - the Doctor deflates the Controller's pompous self-aggrandizement with one cutting quip.
Favourite moment: Had to be the "fast-paced" ATV chase.
Lasting image: Everyone lounging around on the 22nd century cushions.
8/10
Our marathon continues with Story #61: The Curse of Peladon...
Two fans of Doctor Who, one marathon viewing of every episode of the series from 1963 to the present.
Running through corridors is optional.
Running through corridors is optional.
Wednesday, May 29, 2013
Wednesday, May 15, 2013
Story #59 - The Daemons (1971)
Harry -
IO-HE-VO-HE AZAL! (*making double horned signs*)
Season 8 ends on a high note with some folk horror in the village, Doctor Who style.
AZAL! HEAR ME AZAL! (*double horns again*)
Sarah -
It really is the dawning of the Age of Aquarius, Harry!
What an excellent capper to the season -- science, folklore, witchcraft, aliens, and, most absurdly of all, Morris Dancers!
Harry -
The Morris Dancers of Death!
Sarah -
You know how much I love Morris Dancing. The only thing missing from this story is a Local Shop!
Harry -
There was a local pub, with lots of happenings among the locals, so that'll work.
Sarah -
Speaking of, I’d love to see an entire series set in Bert’s Pub!
Christopher Barry does an excellent job of setting the mood, from the creepy crypt to the Beltane revels. In fact, the only part of the story I found disappointing were the Daemons, themselves.
Harry -
I loved the atmosphere of fantastic weirdness woven through the first half of the story.
Jo hints at her belief in the occult and supernatural things. The Doctor scoffs, but nonetheless is very interested in the dig at the bronze age Devil's Hump.
Sarah -
I loved that turnaround. From, “You know, Jo, for a reasonably intelligent young lady, you do have the most absurd ideas” to hitting the road in Bessie within the first episode!
Harry -
Meanwhile, the Master is back on Earth, this time as a black priest performing esoteric ceremonies.
Sarah -
Of course he is. The Master is the idealized version of the complete renaissance villain!
Harry -
Perhaps weirdest of all was seeing Yates and Benton in casual wear. Season 8 has veered in a completely different direction!
Sarah -
When the Brig’s away, the mice will play. Speaking of the Brig, I really wanted him to be wearing a kilt when he went off to his event early in the story. It’s been too long without Jamie and I’m missing kilts.
Harry -
If I recall, we will eventually see the Brig's lovely knees sometime in the future.
Sarah -
An event that I have been eagerly anticipating for a while now.
Happily, Yates and Benton got a lot of screen time in this story and made the most of it. Excellent work by John Levene and Richard Franklin.
Harry -
The casual wear! I loved it! Yates looked like he was off to a book reading, while Benton was going to watch some footy.
Did you have the same thought as me about the announcer at the dig site? It should have been Michael Wisher!
Sarah -
Oh, how I was wishing it would have been Wisher. What a missed opportunity.
Harry -
I liked the curmudgeonly professor, and of course Miss Hawthorne. Another cast of memorable extras rounded this story off.
Sarah -
Miss Hawthorne was especially brilliant. I loved her pluck and commitment to her witchcraft. The scene where the constable picked up the rock to smash her over the head was a bit harrowing, but I loved her confidence in convincing the village that the Doctor was a great wizard who must be freed. Brilliant performance by Damaris Hayman!
Harry -
She was quintessentially English. And some folks think highly enough of her to bring her back in a new film: The White Witch of Devil's End. Amazing!
I'm going to look up what else Damaris Hayman has been in.
Back to the story itself. Good ol' Guy Leopold (ha!) wrote a tale of occult happenings at a small English village that reminded me of several "folk horror" movies made around the same time. The Daemons reminded me of The Wicker Man, Blood on Satan's Claw, and Witchfinder General. These films were built around the premise that pre-Christian beliefs were perverted into something eerie and frightening, with generous lashings of outright Satanism thrown in. So it was delightful to watch the Master don a black priest's garb and recite incantations.
Sarah -
“SO MOTE IT BE!”
Sorry, I’ve always wanted to say that…
Harry -
All the while, the Doctor sensed what was really going on, but he was coy in the early going. He was determined to emphasize science over magic to almost everyone he spoke with in the first two episodes. It was just slightly disappointing when he took Jo down to the dig site and revealed that it was a spaceship down there after all.
Sarah -
It was even more disappointing to learn that the Daemons were responsible for all human advancement. Sheesh, why do we even bother?
Harry -
Yeah, it was odd to get that reveal halfway through the story. But in the grand style of the Barry Letts era, it opened up the remaining episodes to helicopter chases, motorbike action, and of course, the Morris Dancers of Death!
Sarah -
It was complete mayhem in the village – what fun!
Harry -
I particularly liked the barkeep's shredded newspaper wear. I've never seen something like that before or since.
Sarah -
I was thinking that would be a good look on you, Old Boy.
Harry -
I rather fancied the Master's ceremonial robes.
Let's take a moment to review the Master's arc in Season 8. Not sure if it's an arc in the current sense, but for one season of Doctor Who, the Master appeared in every story. We know he was created to be a kind of Moriarty to the Doctor's Holmes. The casting of Roger Delgado was perfect and he played the role brilliantly. Until now, though, I hadn't realized that stories involving the Master follow the same template every time: Master concocts grandiose scheme for power; Doctor investigates and uncovers said scheme; Master realizes the scheme was total rubbish and relies on Doctor's help to get out of trouble; Doctor obliges, Master suffers inferiority complex and flees vowing revenge. It's the same story every time!
Sarah -
It really is the same story every time. I believe I've seen most of these stories as one-offs and never in proper chronological order before. The Master is the Doctor's greatest nemesis and I felt more than a little guilty rolling my eyes at yet another formulaic Master story. As much as I adore Roger Delgado's brilliant performances, I prefer to spread them out a bit.
Harry -
OK, time to stop skirting around the problem here. Yes, it totally sucked that "The Daemons" is all about showing us the Daemons from Daemos, who have influenced all of human history. While the Doctor's proto-powerpoint presentation was illuminating, it was also disappointing.
Sarah -
And BORING!
Harry -
Azal, the last remaining Daemon was so all-powerful (and shouty loud!) that once again, the Master overstepped. It was up to the Doctor and Jo to engage in a, well, a very long chat with Azal. Jo's offer to sacrifice herself utterly blew the Daemon's mind. Kind of a weird ending. But this was a weird story. The atmosphere and cues from contemporary horror films were distinctive and fabulous, but I guess the Doctor Who'd version fell a bit flat at the finish.
Sarah -
Still, the excellent fun of the first four episodes more than made up for the disappointment of the finale. Jo is even (somewhat) vindicated when the Doctor admits, “You’re right, Jo, there is magic in the world, after all.”
The story ends with the Doctor and Jo participating in the Beltane rituals while the Brig and Yates have a pint. Once again, all is right in the world.
So, I have to ask Harry … Pint?
Harry -
I thought you'd never ask, chum.
Sarah -
Best Line: I’ve got to give this one to Miss Hawthorne, reprimanding the Master: “Why should I believe you, a rationalist, existentialist priest, indeed.”
Favorite Moment: The Morris Dancers arrive!
Lasting Image: The Morris Dancers arrive!
8/10
Harry -
Best line: "IO-HE-VO-HE AZAL!" (it's fun to shout and make the double horned signs)
Favourite Moment: The Brigadier remains totally unflappable while reviewing Yates' explanation of the wild goings on in the village. I laughed so hard I had to pause it.
Lasting image: The Master in his ceremonial robes.
8/10
Our marathon continues with Story #60: Day of the Daleks...
IO-HE-VO-HE AZAL! (*making double horned signs*)
Season 8 ends on a high note with some folk horror in the village, Doctor Who style.
AZAL! HEAR ME AZAL! (*double horns again*)
Sarah -
It really is the dawning of the Age of Aquarius, Harry!
What an excellent capper to the season -- science, folklore, witchcraft, aliens, and, most absurdly of all, Morris Dancers!
Harry -
The Morris Dancers of Death!
Sarah -
You know how much I love Morris Dancing. The only thing missing from this story is a Local Shop!
Harry -
There was a local pub, with lots of happenings among the locals, so that'll work.
Sarah -
Speaking of, I’d love to see an entire series set in Bert’s Pub!
Christopher Barry does an excellent job of setting the mood, from the creepy crypt to the Beltane revels. In fact, the only part of the story I found disappointing were the Daemons, themselves.
Harry -
I loved the atmosphere of fantastic weirdness woven through the first half of the story.
Jo hints at her belief in the occult and supernatural things. The Doctor scoffs, but nonetheless is very interested in the dig at the bronze age Devil's Hump.
Sarah -
I loved that turnaround. From, “You know, Jo, for a reasonably intelligent young lady, you do have the most absurd ideas” to hitting the road in Bessie within the first episode!
Harry -
Meanwhile, the Master is back on Earth, this time as a black priest performing esoteric ceremonies.
Sarah -
Of course he is. The Master is the idealized version of the complete renaissance villain!
Harry -
Perhaps weirdest of all was seeing Yates and Benton in casual wear. Season 8 has veered in a completely different direction!
Sarah -
When the Brig’s away, the mice will play. Speaking of the Brig, I really wanted him to be wearing a kilt when he went off to his event early in the story. It’s been too long without Jamie and I’m missing kilts.
Harry -
If I recall, we will eventually see the Brig's lovely knees sometime in the future.
Sarah -
An event that I have been eagerly anticipating for a while now.
Happily, Yates and Benton got a lot of screen time in this story and made the most of it. Excellent work by John Levene and Richard Franklin.
Harry -
The casual wear! I loved it! Yates looked like he was off to a book reading, while Benton was going to watch some footy.
Did you have the same thought as me about the announcer at the dig site? It should have been Michael Wisher!
Sarah -
Oh, how I was wishing it would have been Wisher. What a missed opportunity.
Harry -
I liked the curmudgeonly professor, and of course Miss Hawthorne. Another cast of memorable extras rounded this story off.
Sarah -
Miss Hawthorne was especially brilliant. I loved her pluck and commitment to her witchcraft. The scene where the constable picked up the rock to smash her over the head was a bit harrowing, but I loved her confidence in convincing the village that the Doctor was a great wizard who must be freed. Brilliant performance by Damaris Hayman!
Harry -
She was quintessentially English. And some folks think highly enough of her to bring her back in a new film: The White Witch of Devil's End. Amazing!
I'm going to look up what else Damaris Hayman has been in.
Back to the story itself. Good ol' Guy Leopold (ha!) wrote a tale of occult happenings at a small English village that reminded me of several "folk horror" movies made around the same time. The Daemons reminded me of The Wicker Man, Blood on Satan's Claw, and Witchfinder General. These films were built around the premise that pre-Christian beliefs were perverted into something eerie and frightening, with generous lashings of outright Satanism thrown in. So it was delightful to watch the Master don a black priest's garb and recite incantations.
Sarah -
“SO MOTE IT BE!”
Sorry, I’ve always wanted to say that…
Harry -
All the while, the Doctor sensed what was really going on, but he was coy in the early going. He was determined to emphasize science over magic to almost everyone he spoke with in the first two episodes. It was just slightly disappointing when he took Jo down to the dig site and revealed that it was a spaceship down there after all.
Sarah -
It was even more disappointing to learn that the Daemons were responsible for all human advancement. Sheesh, why do we even bother?
Harry -
Yeah, it was odd to get that reveal halfway through the story. But in the grand style of the Barry Letts era, it opened up the remaining episodes to helicopter chases, motorbike action, and of course, the Morris Dancers of Death!
Sarah -
It was complete mayhem in the village – what fun!
Harry -
I particularly liked the barkeep's shredded newspaper wear. I've never seen something like that before or since.
Sarah -
I was thinking that would be a good look on you, Old Boy.
Harry -
I rather fancied the Master's ceremonial robes.
Let's take a moment to review the Master's arc in Season 8. Not sure if it's an arc in the current sense, but for one season of Doctor Who, the Master appeared in every story. We know he was created to be a kind of Moriarty to the Doctor's Holmes. The casting of Roger Delgado was perfect and he played the role brilliantly. Until now, though, I hadn't realized that stories involving the Master follow the same template every time: Master concocts grandiose scheme for power; Doctor investigates and uncovers said scheme; Master realizes the scheme was total rubbish and relies on Doctor's help to get out of trouble; Doctor obliges, Master suffers inferiority complex and flees vowing revenge. It's the same story every time!
Sarah -
It really is the same story every time. I believe I've seen most of these stories as one-offs and never in proper chronological order before. The Master is the Doctor's greatest nemesis and I felt more than a little guilty rolling my eyes at yet another formulaic Master story. As much as I adore Roger Delgado's brilliant performances, I prefer to spread them out a bit.
Harry -
OK, time to stop skirting around the problem here. Yes, it totally sucked that "The Daemons" is all about showing us the Daemons from Daemos, who have influenced all of human history. While the Doctor's proto-powerpoint presentation was illuminating, it was also disappointing.
Sarah -
And BORING!
Harry -
Azal, the last remaining Daemon was so all-powerful (and shouty loud!) that once again, the Master overstepped. It was up to the Doctor and Jo to engage in a, well, a very long chat with Azal. Jo's offer to sacrifice herself utterly blew the Daemon's mind. Kind of a weird ending. But this was a weird story. The atmosphere and cues from contemporary horror films were distinctive and fabulous, but I guess the Doctor Who'd version fell a bit flat at the finish.
Sarah -
Still, the excellent fun of the first four episodes more than made up for the disappointment of the finale. Jo is even (somewhat) vindicated when the Doctor admits, “You’re right, Jo, there is magic in the world, after all.”
The story ends with the Doctor and Jo participating in the Beltane rituals while the Brig and Yates have a pint. Once again, all is right in the world.
So, I have to ask Harry … Pint?
Harry -
I thought you'd never ask, chum.
Sarah -
Best Line: I’ve got to give this one to Miss Hawthorne, reprimanding the Master: “Why should I believe you, a rationalist, existentialist priest, indeed.”
Favorite Moment: The Morris Dancers arrive!
Lasting Image: The Morris Dancers arrive!
8/10
Harry -
Best line: "IO-HE-VO-HE AZAL!" (it's fun to shout and make the double horned signs)
Favourite Moment: The Brigadier remains totally unflappable while reviewing Yates' explanation of the wild goings on in the village. I laughed so hard I had to pause it.
Lasting image: The Master in his ceremonial robes.
8/10
Our marathon continues with Story #60: Day of the Daleks...
Monday, May 6, 2013
Story #58 - Colony in Space (1971)
Sarah -
The Master’s on the loose and the Time Lords are willing to restore the Doctor’s freedom to serve their own purposes. We’re back in the TARDIS again, Dear Harry!
Harry -
That was an unexpected opening. The Time Lords whisking the Doctor out into space like a game piece and leaving him to sort it out. You can see why he doesn't like them. At least we finally get a space story again.
Sarah -
These Earthbound stories have been excellent, but, like the Doctor, I've been itching to do some traveling. Unfortunately, Jo isn't quite ready for the Doctor's wandering ways.
I must tell you, Old Boy, that I've never seen this story before! I practically squealed with delight when I realized there was still a new story to see.
Harry -
I had this one confused with another one, but I really liked this one.
Sarah -
I was not prepared for Jo's reaction to entering the TARDIS for the first time. We're so used to all companions rushing headlong into the TARDIS, ready for adventure. What a surprise to find that Jo's first reaction was to hightail it out of there!
Harry -
Yeah, Jo takes a huge hit in my estimation here. It's not Katy Manning's fault that she was written to be an 8-year-old child. Once she started playing "frightened", it seemed she'd be spooked by her own shadow. The Doctor stroking her cheek and talking down to her didn't help. Watching all these stories in a row is starting to put a bit of a dampener on my memories of the Pertwee era.
Sarah -
Jo's never been one of my favorite companions, but this isn't one of her finer moments. Isn't she supposed to be UNIT-trained? Shouldn't she have some amount of stiff-upper-lip-ness to see her through?
Harry -
Should have, but let's put aside the poor characterizations and talk about the story. Mac Hulke has given us another cracker. I hadn't really paid attention to which writer wrote which story before we set off on this marathon of ours, Sarah. Hulke is becoming one of my favourite Who writers!
Sarah -
He never lets us down, does he?
Harry -
He gives us a classic confrontation between plucky, self-sufficient pioneers and cruel, corporate mercenaries. The colonists were idealistic and willing to stick it out together, while the Intergalactic Mining Corporation thugs resorted to threats and violence in the name of profit.
Sarah -
With the native primitives tossed in, all that’s missing from this western are a few dramatic shots of Monument Valley. Oh, wait, we’re in space, aren’t we?
Harry -
If Mac Hulke's script wasn't in-your-face enough, the costume design was perfect. The colonists looked like a band of English folk musicians, while the IMC were dressed in fascist-looking uniforms.
Sarah -
Subtle it was not. Still, I find myself wishing they’d broken into a round of Morris dancing... in space!
Harry -
Into this stark black-and-white scenario are plunged the Doctor and Jo. The Doctor immediately sides with the colonists and exposes IMC's sabotage efforts. Captain Dent and his thugs do not appreciate this, and continue their campaign to expel the colonists.
Dent is a fantastic villain. Colder than a snake, and nastier. Hulke didn't give him an ounce of compassion, unlike Caldwell, the miner who gets caught between his job and his conscience.
Sarah -
We’ve seen some baddies before, but chaining Jo and Winton to a bomb is a new low! And let’s not forget that charming sociopath, Morgan.
Harry -
Norton the infiltrator, Winton the agitator, Ashe the doomed leader. So many great characters here, it felt like we really got to know them.
Sarah -
I have to admit that I wasn’t at all looking forward to another six-parter, but I love the room the story had to develop the characters. I found myself becoming quite attached to our merry band of settlers.
Harry -
Then there's the awkwardly named "Primitives." On the surface, they seem to be just that, but once within their city, the Doctor and Jo discover the remnants of a once-brilliant society, one that seemed to regress as a result of experimentation and radiation exposure.
Sarah -
I loved this unexpected twist on the “primitives.” Not that anyone is going to listen to their cautionary tale, mind you.
Harry -
While the Doctor and Jo are in the underground city, the character that the Time Lords hinted at in part one finally arrives in the person of the Adjudicator. Using this façade, the Master aims to enter the underground city and take control of the Primitives' superweapon. It's the latest in a series of plots that have grand objectives but little practicality.
Sarah -
I know the decision was made to include the Master in all the episodes of this season, and I don’t want to be seen questioning Barry Letts decision making… but I guess that’s exactly what I’m doing. Does the Master have a Doctor-homing-device in his TARDIS. His ability to show up wherever the Doctor is – even when his earthly exile is ended – is uncanny.
Harry -
So as we move into the second half of the story, we have a lot going on. The colonists and IMC continue to sabotage and attack one another - highlighted by several close-range gun battles. The Doctor and Jo have discovered the underground city and its people. The Master is worming his way into the thick of things, and the Boards-of-Canada-esque incidental music continues to delight this viewer!
Sarah -
The tension is mounting!
Harry -
I think what made this six-parter work was that the story definitely progressed from one episode to the next, without circling back to repeat itself.
Sarah -
Absolutely! Unlike recent stories, we find ourselves with a fresh cliffhanger for each episode. Things keep moving along at a brisk clip.
Our pioneers find themselves agreeing to leave the planet to the mining thugs, which leads us to one of the most devastating moments of the series so far – shortly after taking off, the settlers spaceship explodes. I was devastated and couldn’t believe Doctor Who was doing this to me.
But Wait! It was all a ploy! Ashe bravely piloted the spaceship on his own, knowing it wouldn’t fly – saving the rest of the colony! I nearly stood up and cheered!
Harry -
Ashe gave everything in order to make the colony succeed, including his life. Not that I keep a ranking of such things, but his death was especially tragic.
Sarah -
It was utterly heartbreaking.
Harry -
Meanwhile, the Master once again tempts the Doctor with a half-share of All The Power In The Universe. The Doctor seems to mull it over before he shoots the Master down again. All these failures and rejections in short order must take a toll on the Master's fragile psyche - no wonder he goes increasingly bonkers as a character.
Sarah -
This is getting a bit old, to be honest. Too much Master in a row.
Harry -
Things are quickly wrapped up as the Primitives' tiny elder decides to destroy the superweapon, taking their city with it. Our heroes escape, the Master flees, the colonists are left to start over, and the TARDIS returns to UNIT HQ mere seconds after the Brigadier called it back. Nicely done!
Sarah -
The Doctor returning to UNIT HQ on the Brig’s command was priceless.
Best Line:
Caldwell -- “Are you some kind of Scientist?”
Doctor -- “I’m every kind of scientist.”
Favorite Moment: The Doctor reveals he has the Master’s TARDIS key.
Lasting Image: The settlers on the hill after the ship explodes. Just this once, everybody lives!
7/10
Harry -
Everybody lives... except Ashe. He's going to haunt us!
Best line: Ha! We picked the same one. Hugs all round.
Favourite moment: The TARDIS returns to UNIT HQ, seemingly on the Brig's command.
Lasting image: Dent's cold, stone face of corporate contempt.
7/10
Our marathon continues with Story #59 - The Daemons...
The Master’s on the loose and the Time Lords are willing to restore the Doctor’s freedom to serve their own purposes. We’re back in the TARDIS again, Dear Harry!
Harry -
That was an unexpected opening. The Time Lords whisking the Doctor out into space like a game piece and leaving him to sort it out. You can see why he doesn't like them. At least we finally get a space story again.
Sarah -
These Earthbound stories have been excellent, but, like the Doctor, I've been itching to do some traveling. Unfortunately, Jo isn't quite ready for the Doctor's wandering ways.
I must tell you, Old Boy, that I've never seen this story before! I practically squealed with delight when I realized there was still a new story to see.
Harry -
I had this one confused with another one, but I really liked this one.
Sarah -
I was not prepared for Jo's reaction to entering the TARDIS for the first time. We're so used to all companions rushing headlong into the TARDIS, ready for adventure. What a surprise to find that Jo's first reaction was to hightail it out of there!
Harry -
Yeah, Jo takes a huge hit in my estimation here. It's not Katy Manning's fault that she was written to be an 8-year-old child. Once she started playing "frightened", it seemed she'd be spooked by her own shadow. The Doctor stroking her cheek and talking down to her didn't help. Watching all these stories in a row is starting to put a bit of a dampener on my memories of the Pertwee era.
Sarah -
Jo's never been one of my favorite companions, but this isn't one of her finer moments. Isn't she supposed to be UNIT-trained? Shouldn't she have some amount of stiff-upper-lip-ness to see her through?
Harry -
Should have, but let's put aside the poor characterizations and talk about the story. Mac Hulke has given us another cracker. I hadn't really paid attention to which writer wrote which story before we set off on this marathon of ours, Sarah. Hulke is becoming one of my favourite Who writers!
Sarah -
He never lets us down, does he?
Harry -
He gives us a classic confrontation between plucky, self-sufficient pioneers and cruel, corporate mercenaries. The colonists were idealistic and willing to stick it out together, while the Intergalactic Mining Corporation thugs resorted to threats and violence in the name of profit.
Sarah -
With the native primitives tossed in, all that’s missing from this western are a few dramatic shots of Monument Valley. Oh, wait, we’re in space, aren’t we?
Harry -
If Mac Hulke's script wasn't in-your-face enough, the costume design was perfect. The colonists looked like a band of English folk musicians, while the IMC were dressed in fascist-looking uniforms.
Sarah -
Subtle it was not. Still, I find myself wishing they’d broken into a round of Morris dancing... in space!
Harry -
Into this stark black-and-white scenario are plunged the Doctor and Jo. The Doctor immediately sides with the colonists and exposes IMC's sabotage efforts. Captain Dent and his thugs do not appreciate this, and continue their campaign to expel the colonists.
Dent is a fantastic villain. Colder than a snake, and nastier. Hulke didn't give him an ounce of compassion, unlike Caldwell, the miner who gets caught between his job and his conscience.
Sarah -
We’ve seen some baddies before, but chaining Jo and Winton to a bomb is a new low! And let’s not forget that charming sociopath, Morgan.
Harry -
Norton the infiltrator, Winton the agitator, Ashe the doomed leader. So many great characters here, it felt like we really got to know them.
Sarah -
I have to admit that I wasn’t at all looking forward to another six-parter, but I love the room the story had to develop the characters. I found myself becoming quite attached to our merry band of settlers.
Harry -
Then there's the awkwardly named "Primitives." On the surface, they seem to be just that, but once within their city, the Doctor and Jo discover the remnants of a once-brilliant society, one that seemed to regress as a result of experimentation and radiation exposure.
Sarah -
I loved this unexpected twist on the “primitives.” Not that anyone is going to listen to their cautionary tale, mind you.
Harry -
While the Doctor and Jo are in the underground city, the character that the Time Lords hinted at in part one finally arrives in the person of the Adjudicator. Using this façade, the Master aims to enter the underground city and take control of the Primitives' superweapon. It's the latest in a series of plots that have grand objectives but little practicality.
Sarah -
I know the decision was made to include the Master in all the episodes of this season, and I don’t want to be seen questioning Barry Letts decision making… but I guess that’s exactly what I’m doing. Does the Master have a Doctor-homing-device in his TARDIS. His ability to show up wherever the Doctor is – even when his earthly exile is ended – is uncanny.
Harry -
So as we move into the second half of the story, we have a lot going on. The colonists and IMC continue to sabotage and attack one another - highlighted by several close-range gun battles. The Doctor and Jo have discovered the underground city and its people. The Master is worming his way into the thick of things, and the Boards-of-Canada-esque incidental music continues to delight this viewer!
Sarah -
The tension is mounting!
Harry -
I think what made this six-parter work was that the story definitely progressed from one episode to the next, without circling back to repeat itself.
Sarah -
Absolutely! Unlike recent stories, we find ourselves with a fresh cliffhanger for each episode. Things keep moving along at a brisk clip.
Our pioneers find themselves agreeing to leave the planet to the mining thugs, which leads us to one of the most devastating moments of the series so far – shortly after taking off, the settlers spaceship explodes. I was devastated and couldn’t believe Doctor Who was doing this to me.
But Wait! It was all a ploy! Ashe bravely piloted the spaceship on his own, knowing it wouldn’t fly – saving the rest of the colony! I nearly stood up and cheered!
Harry -
Ashe gave everything in order to make the colony succeed, including his life. Not that I keep a ranking of such things, but his death was especially tragic.
Sarah -
It was utterly heartbreaking.
Harry -
Meanwhile, the Master once again tempts the Doctor with a half-share of All The Power In The Universe. The Doctor seems to mull it over before he shoots the Master down again. All these failures and rejections in short order must take a toll on the Master's fragile psyche - no wonder he goes increasingly bonkers as a character.
Sarah -
This is getting a bit old, to be honest. Too much Master in a row.
Harry -
Things are quickly wrapped up as the Primitives' tiny elder decides to destroy the superweapon, taking their city with it. Our heroes escape, the Master flees, the colonists are left to start over, and the TARDIS returns to UNIT HQ mere seconds after the Brigadier called it back. Nicely done!
Sarah -
The Doctor returning to UNIT HQ on the Brig’s command was priceless.
Best Line:
Caldwell -- “Are you some kind of Scientist?”
Doctor -- “I’m every kind of scientist.”
Favorite Moment: The Doctor reveals he has the Master’s TARDIS key.
Lasting Image: The settlers on the hill after the ship explodes. Just this once, everybody lives!
7/10
Harry -
Everybody lives... except Ashe. He's going to haunt us!
Best line: Ha! We picked the same one. Hugs all round.
Favourite moment: The TARDIS returns to UNIT HQ, seemingly on the Brig's command.
Lasting image: Dent's cold, stone face of corporate contempt.
7/10
Our marathon continues with Story #59 - The Daemons...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)